What is the rule for base runners during an appeal play?

• A. Runners may advance at their own risk.
• B. Runners must return to their bases and are not allowed to advance until the appeal is resolved.
• C. Runners may stay where they are regardless of the appeal.
• D. Runners are awarded an additional base if they appeal.

Answer: (B)

During an appeal play in NCAA softball, the general rule is that base runners must return to their bases and are not allowed to advance until the appeal is resolved. This is crucial because the appeal is a formal process in which the defensive team points out a potential infraction that occurred during the play. While the appeal is being made, the status of the runners is effectively paused—meaning they cannot advance, since the play has not officially concluded.

This rule is designed to maintain the integrity of the game, ensuring fairness during situations where a defensive play requires an official judgment. If runners were allowed to advance during an appeal, it could lead to significant confusion and unfair advantage. By requiring runners to return to their original bases until the appeal is determined, the NCAA rules provide a clear framework for handling these situations and ensure the game is played in an orderly manner.