In a batting-out-of-order situation, if a player hits when they shouldn't have, who is called out upon appeal?

• A. Abel
• B. Baker
• C. Chance
• D. Davis

Answer: (C)

In a batting-out-of-order situation, the correct outcome is that the player who should have been batting is declared out upon the defensive team's appeal. Therefore, if Chance is identified as the player who should have batted instead of the player who mistakenly stepped up to hit, Chance would be called out.

The rules specifically state that if the batting order is incorrect and an appeal is made, the actual player who should have been up at that moment is the one who is penalized, which in this case is Chance. This emphasizes the importance of adhering to the batting order during a game, as it can significantly impact the flow of the game and potential scoring opportunities.

In a situation like this, the appeal serves to rectify the error made during the game, ensuring that the correct player takes their turn at bat in accordance with the established order.